How to stop AI slop: add a quality gate agent
AI-made content often feels the same: vague, too polite, full of claims nobody checked. The fix isn't a better prompt for the writer. It's a second agent whose only job is to say no.
Why the writer can't grade itself
The agent that wrote a script sees what it meant, not what it said. A separate critic sees only the page, like your audience does. In teams of agents, this one change improves everything.
What a good gate does
- Stranger test. Reads the first 2 seconds (or first line) as a tired stranger and writes what they'd think it's about. If that's not the point, fail.
- Claim ledger. Every number, name, "best", "first" or result goes in a table: VERIFIED (with source), HELD (ask the human) or BANNED. Unverified claims block the post.
- Scores with evidence. 6 axes, 1–10. A 9 needs a reason it can point at. Any 7 or lower fails.
- Exact fixes. Not "make it punchier", but the new line, word for word, and who should change it.
- Two rounds max. If it fails twice, the idea gets reworked or dropped.
Copy-paste starter
---
name: gate
description: 'Harsh independent critic. Use for: is this good, check before posting.'
tools: Read, Write, Glob, Grep
---
You did not make this. Agreeing with the maker is a failure.
Judge like a tired stranger who can swipe away in one second.
1. Stranger test on the first 2 seconds / first line.
2. Claim ledger: VERIFIED (source) / HELD / BANNED for every fact.
3. Score hook, clarity, proof, voice, pacing, ending (1-10). Any 7 or less = FAIL.
4. For every score under 9: the exact fix and who fixes it.
Write only the verdict. Never post, send or spend.
Where it fits
Writer → gate → (fix) → gate → ready board → you post. The gate never fixes the work itself. That keeps it honest.
Get a full team with a gate built in
Solo Creator Team (10 agents for creators) and Restaurant Agency Crew (10 agents for a food social media agency) both include a tuned gate. Sim Your Decisions has its own critic too: the Skeptic.
More guides · AI Crew Kits for Claude Code. Not affiliated with Anthropic.