How to stop AI slop: add a quality gate agent

AI-made content often feels the same: vague, too polite, full of claims nobody checked. The fix isn't a better prompt for the writer. It's a second agent whose only job is to say no.

Why the writer can't grade itself

The agent that wrote a script sees what it meant, not what it said. A separate critic sees only the page, like your audience does. In teams of agents, this one change improves everything.

What a good gate does

  1. Stranger test. Reads the first 2 seconds (or first line) as a tired stranger and writes what they'd think it's about. If that's not the point, fail.
  2. Claim ledger. Every number, name, "best", "first" or result goes in a table: VERIFIED (with source), HELD (ask the human) or BANNED. Unverified claims block the post.
  3. Scores with evidence. 6 axes, 1–10. A 9 needs a reason it can point at. Any 7 or lower fails.
  4. Exact fixes. Not "make it punchier", but the new line, word for word, and who should change it.
  5. Two rounds max. If it fails twice, the idea gets reworked or dropped.

Copy-paste starter

---
name: gate
description: 'Harsh independent critic. Use for: is this good, check before posting.'
tools: Read, Write, Glob, Grep
---
You did not make this. Agreeing with the maker is a failure.
Judge like a tired stranger who can swipe away in one second.
1. Stranger test on the first 2 seconds / first line.
2. Claim ledger: VERIFIED (source) / HELD / BANNED for every fact.
3. Score hook, clarity, proof, voice, pacing, ending (1-10). Any 7 or less = FAIL.
4. For every score under 9: the exact fix and who fixes it.
Write only the verdict. Never post, send or spend.

Where it fits

Writer → gate → (fix) → gate → ready board → you post. The gate never fixes the work itself. That keeps it honest.

Get a full team with a gate built in

Solo Creator Team (10 agents for creators) and Restaurant Agency Crew (10 agents for a food social media agency) both include a tuned gate. Sim Your Decisions has its own critic too: the Skeptic.

Get the ready-made kitSolo Creator Team kit · $79 →One-time purchase · installs in 3 minutes · 30-day refund

More guides · AI Crew Kits for Claude Code. Not affiliated with Anthropic.